HebrewGrade 10ages 15–16
✂️ Cut without erasing
Editing for length only works when the words removed were repeating something already said — cut past that point and the idea itself goes missing, not just the excess.
Try this lesson freeNo card needed. The first lesson is free.
Download on the App StoreWhat your child learns
- A cut is safe when the words removed only repeated what was already said.
- The test: after the cut, does the reader answer every question he answered before?
- If an answer went missing, that is no longer tightening but deletion.
- The door is closed, fully closed, really closed — all of them answer the same.
The mistake most kids make here
Any shortening is good, even when the idea vanishes.
Try one question
Tightening
- the door is closed
- the door
- closed closed closed
Answer
the door is closed — Yes. Fully and really only intensified what was already said.
How Maya teaches it
Your child tells Maya what they did in class. She teaches this topic at her desk, asks questions with tappable answers, and when the answer is wrong she explains why that answer was tempting instead of saying “try again”. She remembers what did not land and comes back to it.
Your child has it when they can: הדלת סגורה three times becomes הדלת סגורה. Not only הדלת.
How to help at home
A teenager told to 'shorten this' often treats every word as equally cuttable, when really some words are carrying the one idea and others are just restating it. The skill is telling those two apart before cutting anything.
Try this tonight: take three sentences that all say the same thing in different words (like 'the door is closed', 'the door is fully closed', 'the door is really closed') and ask your teen which single sentence would answer every question the other two answer. That's the safe cut.
When a cut removes the idea instead of the repetition, don't just say 'you lost the point' — ask 'if a stranger only read your short version, could they still answer the same question the long version answered?' If not, something essential went with the fat.
A good sign they've got it: after cutting, they can point to which specific word or phrase was doing the actual work, and show it's still there.
Questions parents ask
- Why does my child's writing lose its point when asked to make it shorter?
- They're often cutting words at random rather than testing which words are essential versus repetitive. The fix is checking, before cutting, whether a stranger could still answer the same question after the cut.
- What's a simple rule for shortening a sentence safely?
- If two phrases in a sentence answer the exact same question, keep one and drop the other. If every phrase answers a different question, nothing there is safe to cut.
- Is this the same as 'show don't tell'?
- No — this is about removing repetition without removing information, which is a separate skill from vividness. A sentence can be vivid and still repeat itself, or plain and say everything once.
- How does Maya teach this differently from a worksheet?
- Maya shows three versions of one idea at different lengths and asks the child to pick the shortest one that still answers everything the longest one answers, so the test is concrete rather than a rule to memorize.
No card needed. The first lesson is free.
Download on the App StoreMore Hebrew lessons
- Request and commandGrade 10
- Who it is written forGrade 10
- How they differGrade 9
- The opposite of what is meantGrade 9
- One clear claim sentenceGrade 9
- Claim and evidenceGrade 8
- A counterclaimGrade 8
- Formal or spokenGrade 8